People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. When I contacted PETA for a comment on these numbers, Amanda Schinke, a spokesperson for the organization, sent a thoughtful and detailed response. Not only does PETA kill animals, they also defend the killing of animals by others. PETA is still around due to a technicality that allows for 70% kill rate “shelters” to be legally called animal shelters. So PETA advertised it a lot & said that this person was an activist for animals, etc. Performing a virtual psychological vivisection, Winograd diagnoses Newkirk as a "disturbed person," a "shameless animal killer," and the executrix of a "bloody reign" of terror over dogs and cats. Diamond was suffering from a painful facial tumor that was slowly eating away at his face. Current subscribers: You will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Santana had facial injuries so severe that his right eye was swollen shut and his jaw was torn open and hanging. Why does PETA kill so many animals that they rescue? I would get laid all the time to save my species and on top of that they feed me and clean up my feces. They are a … Tweet. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com. You also know that PETA rounds up and kills animals every year. According to PETA’s own filings, in 2004 PETA killed 86.3 percent of the animals entrusted to its care — a number that’s rising, not falling.. Since 2001, PETA’s low- to no-cost spay-and-neuter mobile clinics have sterilized nearly 170,000 animals, preventing hundreds of thousands of unwanted puppies and kittens from being born, neglected, abandoned, abused, or euthanized. I would be able to help my species with harmless tests. Since 1998, PETA has been directly responsible for the death of 41,539 animals. Get breaking news and the latest headlines on business, entertainment, politics, world news, tech, sports, videos and much more from AOL Stay up to date on the latest vegan trends and get breaking animal rights news delivered straight to your inbox! In 2011, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) behaved in a regrettably consistent manner: it euthanized the overwhelming majority (PDF) of dogs and cats that it accepted into its shelters. So, how does euthanasia fit into PETA’s work to alleviate suffering? Man Shoots His Dog, Then Barbecues the Body on His Front Lawn, New PETA Kids Comic: These Kids Refuse to Hatch Chicks in Class, Negligence, Abuse, and … Fatal Fires? It is a lie because testimony under oath in court from a veterinarian showed that PETA was given healthy and adoptable animals who were later found dead by PETA's hands, their bodies unceremoniously thrown away in a supermarket dumpster. Your dog begs for handouts, hoping for a stray scrap to savor. The animal rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals doesn't shy away from controversy. All Rights When he was found, he was near death. Why do they have a cadaver refrigerator? If you want to save lives, always have your animals spayed or neutered. That's what PETA does. In it she explained how "euthanasia is a product of love for animals who have no one to love them." i am umamageswaran, from madurai, Tamilnadu, India, as much i hate peta as deep of my soul. Him being an public figure using a specific event to accuse PeTA of killing adoptable animals and obtaining animals under false pretenses despite PeTA having been cleared in a court of law. How can anyone fail to recognize that there is a world of difference between painlessly euthanizing animals—the aged, injured, sick, and dying, whose guardians can’t afford euthanasia, for instance—out of compassion, as PETA does, and causing them terror, pain, and a prolonged death by leaving them to struggle to survive on the streets, at the hands of untrained and uncaring “technicians,” or animal abusers? We go so far as to transport animals to and from our mobile clinics, where they are spayed or neutered and given veterinary care, often free of charge. It’s worth noting that the website ‘Peta Kills Animals’ might have its own agenda! In one year PETA-> PETA RESCUED- 2,107 nice! He also observes that the numbers PETA reports historically come from Virginia, which compiles data only for animals taken into custody "for the purpose of adoption." PETA also took in 58 other companion animals -- including rabbits. Look past the rage, though, and it becomes clear that Winograd has an important case to make. 3.) One piece of kid-targeted PETA literature tells small children: “Your Mommy Kills Animals!” PETA brags that its messages reach over 1.2 million minor children, including 30,000 kids between the ages of 6 and 12, all contacted by e-mail without parental supervision. PETA also works every day to prevent animals from ending up abused, homeless, and euthanized in the first place—a fact that the CCF never mentions on its PETA Kills Animals website. Others were indeed someone’s beloved companion, but they were elderly, sick, injured, dying, aggressive, or otherwise unadoptable, and PETA offered them a painless release from suffering, with no charge to their owners or guardians. Where exactly is your confusion? PETA also took in 58 other companion animals -- including rabbits. For those who have been following my work, you already know that PETA is being sued for taking and killing Maya, a family’s dog. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA; /ˈpiːtə/ stylized as PeTA) is an American animal […] To which Newkirk responds: "If we get them, if we cannot find a home, absolutely.". The more I learn about PETA, the less I think of them. The sweet treat can lead to illness and even death in dogs.Vets say it’s one of the most common causes of dog poisoning.. You do realize the JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure abridged series already made this joke, right? What we see on a daily basis is enough to make you lose faith in humanity. As stated by the People of Ethical Treatments for Animals (PETA), “If zoos really wanted to save animals from extinction, they would be helping protect animals’ natural habitats and not keeping them in prisons.” The rescued endangered animals get harmed in the long run. Big Girl was still alive when a fieldworker found her. It killed 54 of them. TheAtlantic.com Copyright (c) 2021 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. PETA puts a high proportion of animals down, Nachminovitch explains, because it ministers to those that many other shelters turn away, often because of the shelters’ ”no kill” policies. And on a national level, PETA focuses on the root of the problem through our celebrity spay/neuter campaigns. PETA also lobbies to get labs to more humanely treat the animals they experiment on and ultimately kill, and they lobby the factory farms and slaughter houses to more humanely house and kill their animals. With PETA now trending, many have taken to social media to point out how PETA does, in fact, kill animals. Most of the animals we help have known nothing but quarantine conditions … A recent blog post attempted to explain why PETA kills animals at the rate that it does. Scroll down for video Most of the animals we house, rescue, find homes for, or put out of their misery come from abysmal conditions, which often lead to successful prosecution and the banning of animal abusers from ever owning or abusing animals again. This is a dying kitten in a Houston shelter after staff "lost" the kitten. A 501 (c) (3), the ASPCA files an IRS Form 990 annually which provides financial information on the organization to the… Lind January 10, 2015 at 5:39 pm. Ringling Bros. A user tweeted, "When I was followed by the PETA manager of communications on Twitter, I asked her why PETA's kill rate is more than DOUBLE the national average. An Animal’s Place By Michael Pollan The New York Times Magazine, November 10, 2002. Some animals were still conscious, flailing and kicking, even minutes after workers tried to kill them. I repeatedly phoned PETA, but never reached an official who would answer my questions. PETA dubiously claims it does not run a “traditional animal shelter” and that it puts down animals that are too sick or injured to carry on. Please, if you care about animals, help prevent more of them from being born only to end up chained and left to waste away in someone’s backyard, suffering on the mean streets where people just kick them or shoo them away, tortured at the hands of animal abusers, or, tragically, euthanized in an animal shelter for lack of a good home. Sorry to not write well in English. Now there […] By submitting this form, you are agreeing to our collection, storage, use, and disclosure of your personal info in accordance with our privacy policy as well as to receiving e-mails from us. PETA kills dogs all the time, so why aren’t they protesting themselves? Winograd, however, argues persuasively that PETA euthanizes far more than just the unadoptable cases. For Animals, Roadside Zoos Really Are Hell on Earth, Kim Kowdashian? The first time I opened Peter Singer’s “Animal Liberation,” I was dining alone at the Palm, trying to enjoy a rib-eye steak cooked medium-rare. … Yes I think so. But even if his argument is only half right, an animal rights organization with a $30 million budget should be able to do a whole lot better. Why does PETA kill animals that might otherwise find a home? Euthanasia is not a solution to overpopulation but rather a heartbreaking necessity given the current crisis. Is water wet? This dog was suffering from an advanced stage of cancer. Winograd asserts that PETA's failure to find homes for impounded companion animals is the result of founder Ingrid Newkirk's "dark impulses." Who are ‘Peta Kills Animals’? But is this really a simple math problem? We pursued criminal charges against those responsible for her condition, leading to their conviction for cruelty to animals. Anyone has a right to criticize an organization that advocates loudly for animal rights while also treating these animals such a way. When friends have asked me why PETA euthanizes animals, I remind them of Sequoia, my childhood canine companion and—for more than a decade—my best friend. When animals are exploited for human profit, cruelty is never far behind. PETA implies that the animals it kills are mostly near death’s door. acertainauthor January 10, 2015 at 9:41 pm. In contrast, one might say that the animals get rescued. PETA has attempted to defend its death rate on the ground that, unlike other shelters in Virginia, PETA takes in the hard cases that other shelters turn down. “Almost all of us grew up eating meat, wearing leather, and going to circuses and zoos. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA; / ˈ p iː t ə /, stylized as PeTA) is an American animal rights organization based in Norfolk, Virginia, and led by Ingrid Newkirk, its international president.The nonprofit corporation claims 6.5 million supporters. We never considered the impact of these actions on the animals involved. PETA India Names Rescued Cow After Reality Star, Wildly Dangerous California Event With Live Bear Prompts PETA Call to the Feds. When the data on PETA dropped, he posted a scathing article insisting that the organization's almost 100 percent kill rate was due not to laziness or poor management but to "something more nefarious." There are good reasons to believe this claim is inaccurate. It's impossible to tell the story of PETA's specialized shelter without talking a little about Ingrid Newkirk. For whatever reason, you are now asking the question: Why should animals have rights?” READ MORE, — Ingrid E. Newkirk, PETA President and co-author of Animalkind. Even acknowledging that PETA sterilized over 10,500 dogs and cats and returned them to their owners, it doesn't change the fact that its adoption rate in 2011 was 2.5 percent for dogs and 0.4 for cats. If it's so bad that PETA kills animals, then why do people support animal agriculture, which kills far more animals. Is PETA real? They were unsocialized, never having been inside a building of any kind or ever experienced a scratch behind the ears. Joining the likes of Pamela Anderson and Khloe Kardashian, the 48-year-old has stripped naked to pose for PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals). He goes on: It is a lie because rescue groups and individuals have come forward stating that the animals they gave PETA were healthy and adoptable. These figures don't reflect well on an organization dedicated to the cause of animal rights. Peta says the animals it puts down are often turned away by other shelters. ‘Peta’ one of the many animal rights groups had only 18 members just four years ago. Every day, PETA’s fieldworkers help abused and neglected dogs—many of whom are pit bulls often forced to spend their lives on chains heavy enough to tow an 18-wheeler—by providing them with food; clean water; lightweight tie-outs; deworming medicine; flea, tick, and flystrike prevention; free veterinary care; sturdy wooden doghouses stuffed with straw bedding; and attention. I thought PETA loved animals. WASHINGTON, DC – Today, the Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) released an affidavit revealing shocking information about People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) as the animal-rights organization faces a $9 million lawsuit for stealing and killing a man’s dog in Virginia. It is a lie because, according to The Daily Caller, "two PETA employees described as 'adorable' and 'perfect' some of the dogs and cats they killed in the back of a PETA-owned van.". It killed 54 of them. In 2019, PETA killed 65.2% of the animals they received. People may throw stones at us, but we are against all needless killing: for hamburgers, fur collars, dissection, sport hunting—the works. to experiment on, eat, wear, use for entertainment, or abuse in any other way. And even acknowledging that PETA is often the first to rescue pets when heat waves and hurricanes hit, that doesn't change the fact that, at one of its shelters, it kills 84 percent of supposedly "unadoptable" animals within 24 hours of their arrival. Terms for automated texts/calls from PETA: go to a shelter and adopt one or two animals, Every day, PETA’s fieldworkers help abused and neglected dogs, always have your animals spayed or neutered, Learn More About PETA’s Campaigns to Help Animals. As long as companion animals are still deliberately bred and people aren’t spaying and neutering their dogs and cats, open-admission animal shelters and organizations like PETA must do society’s dirty work. There is good reason to believe this is not true. Does PETA Really Care About Animals? Ya clearly I would. PETA, Organisation Behind Jallikattu Ban, Responsible For Deaths Of 34,000 Animals Since 1998 Indian students calling for a ban on PETA at Marina Beach in Chennai. The problem is that few people do that, choosing instead to go to a breeder or a pet shop and not “fixing” their dogs and cats, which contributes to the high euthanasia rate that animal shelters have to face. Here at PETA, we see horrible animal abuse cases day after day. Out of 760 dogs impounded, they killed 713, arranged for 19 to be adopted, and farmed out 36 to other shelters (not necessarily "no kill" ones). Why Do We Euthanize? So a few months after that they show her going to a circus (with animals!). Most people know her as PETA's fearless and controversial founder and leader, but before she helped found PETA in 1980, and devoted her life to saving animals exploited for food, clothing, entertainment, and research, Ingrid Newkirk devoted her life to saving companion animals. She suffered from three painful and deadly intestinal obstructions, which prevented her from keeping any food down, and faced an agonizing, lingering death, so our veterinarian recommended euthanasia to end her suffering. Yes, PETA cares about animals—it’s why we take uncompromising stands on animal rights.And our stances (including our position on euthanasia) always support our driving mission: to stop animal abuse worldwide.. It’s because we care about animals, including those kept as companions, that we provide services in our community: In … People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) has conducted multiple undercover investigations of circuses like Ringling Bros., Shrine, and Carson and Barnes. We go so far as to transport animals to and from our mobile clinics, where they are spayed or neutered and given veterinary care, often free of charge. The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) works to ensure the safety and protection of animals through education, animal health services, anti-cruelty operations, community outreach, disaster/emergency services, and government relations. PETA, considered by many to be the highest-profile animal rights group in the country, kills an average of about 2,000 dogs and cats each year at its animal shelter here. His last hours were ones of suffering. This is another way of saying that because PETA accepts so many dire cases, cases in which euthanasia may very well be justified, it should be excused for killing over 99 percent of the animals under its care. And our stances (including our position on euthanasia) always support our driving mission: to stop animal abuse worldwide. I do! Noting that PETA, unlike many "no-kill" shelters, turns no animal away, Schinke added, "we do everything in our power to help these animals." At one point, he even compares her to nurses who get a thrill from killing their human patients. Even acknowleding that PETA never turns an animal away -- "the sick, the scarred and broken, the elderly, the aggressive and unsocialized..." -- doesn't change the fact that Virginia animal shelters as a whole had a much lower kill rate of 44 percent. Reserved. Our Cruelty Investigations Department is on call 24/7, helping animals and making sure that those who abuse them are held accountable. If this sounds like a good recipe for cognitive dissonance (if not indigestion), that was sort of the idea. An estimated 26 million animals are used every year in the United States for scientific and commercial testing. To anyone who donates to PETA, stop it. If anyone has a good home, love, and respect to offer, please go to a shelter and adopt one or two animals. Why PETA Kills is a quick read and the perfect gift for the PETA supporter on your holiday gift list. One pit bull we gained custody of, named Asia, looked like a skeleton covered with skin when PETA released her from the 15-pound chain that had restricted her for years. Circus. Most of the animals we took in and euthanized could hardly be called “pets,” as they had spent their entire lives penned or chained up outside. Since PETAKillsAnimals.com debuted in 2005, people have frequently asked PETA why it kills so many animals. Yes, PETA cares about animals—it’s why we take uncompromising stands on animal rights. She called their killing a "tragic reality," one that forthrightly acknowledges how "sometimes [animals] need the comfort of being put out of their misery -- a painless release from a world in which they were abused and unwanted." [] Animals are used to develop medical treatments, determine the toxicity of medications, check the safety of products destined for human use, and other biomedical, commercial, and health care uses.Research on living animals has been practiced since at least 500 BC. The story of them killing animals isn’t even unusual. These figures don't reflect well on an organization dedicated to the cause of animal rights. The views expressed on this website are the intellectual property of its creator and are not necessarily reflective of the views of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA). As for cats, they impounded 1,211, euthanized 1,198, transferred eight, and found homes for a grand total of five. You cannot defend the life of some animals and kill others, that makes Peta, WSPA and other evil organizations. Just Food: Where Locavores Get It Wrong and How We Can Truly Eat Responsibly. In PETA's response to me, Schinke wrote, "Winograd dishonestly and viciously attacks all open admission shelters, those that do not shut the door to any animal, even those for whom peaceful release is a mercy." In an email to me, Winograd elaborated, noting that when The Daily Caller asked PETA "what sort of effort it routinely makes to find adoptive homes for animals in its care," PETA responded with the ever convenient "no comment." Animal testing is when they use animals to test out cosmetics, medicinal products, household cleaners, chemicals, etc (Humane Society International). So I wrote a letter to PETA and told them about Holly Madison being such an “activist” yet she was going to a circus to watch animals … PETA is proud to be a “shelter of last resort,” where animals who have no place to turn or who are unwanted or suffering are welcomed with loving open arms. A. UMAMAGESWARAN says. So yes, Winograd is angry. Let those who support PETA know how their donations are actually spent to fund the salaries of the employees who round up and kill, to purchase the lethal drugs used to poison animals, and to pay the renderer who disposes of the bodies of PETA’s thousands of victims every year. Its slogan is "Animals are not ours to experiment on, eat, wear, use for entertainment, or abuse in any other way. End Animal Homelessness PETA Saves Animals The “No-Kill” Shell Game W hile COVID-19 brought many aspects of our lives to a standstill, there was no working from home for PETA’s field team. 99% of the time the habitats are really good too. And then she denied she was their manager of communications. PETA says they will “take in” animals which nobody wants, which is why their kill rate is so high. January 5, 2017 at 2:04 am. It’s easy to point the finger at those who are forced to do the “dirty work” caused by a throwaway society’s casual acquisition and breeding of dogs and cats who end up homeless and unwanted, but at PETA, we will never turn our backs on neglected, unloved, or homeless animals—even if the best we can offer them is a painless release from a world that doesn’t have enough room for them in its heart or homes. Sasha had a severely infected bite wound. But when it comes to sharing your favorite foods with your canine pal, there’s one snack you have to hold back: chocolate. In 2019, PETA helped more than 26,000 companion animals in more than 250 cities, including by providing more than 12,500 dogs and cats with spay/neuter services. Reply. PETA KILLED- … As the years pass, more and more animals are being terrorized and are being used for testing. Healthy mother cat and two kittens killed by PETA within minutes, despite promising to find them a home. Why are PETA employees instructed to acquire animals by any means necessary — which has included lying and theft — in order to kill those animals? The word “euthanasia” comes from two Greek words—“eu” meaning “good” and “thanatos” meaning “death.” Euthanasia is defined as a merciful release from life in order to end suffering. Many animal lovers who have publicly condemned PETA for their killing have received a letter from the PETA legal department, threatening a lawsuit. It simply explains why his statements are false and demands that he removes the defamatory statements from his blog. After doing a little research I was appaled at the staggering amount at which they kill cats and dogs. While PETA claims the animals it takes in and kills are “unadoptable,” the facts do not support this claim. Why do they encourage others to kill them? Larry January 10, 2015 at 6:42 pm >abridged series Abridged series haven’t been good in years. Furthermore, nowhere in the letter does it threaten to take legal action. We want to hear what you think about this article. Meanwhile, the SPCA in PETA’s home town (Norfolk, Va.) was able to find loving homes for 73 percent of the animals put in its care. Why does PETA kill thousands of dogs and cats every year? Does PETA actually help animals? The organization, which claims to be dedicated to the cause of animal rights, can't explain why its adoption rate is only 2.5 percent for dogs. Winograd, a Stanford Law graduate and former corporate lawyer, is the author of Irreconcilable Differences: The Battle for the Heart and Soul of America's Animal Shelters. If you are like us, you have probably spent a good deal of time scratching your head wondering what kind of person would do such horrible things. Noting that PETA, unlike many "no-kill" shelters, turns no animal away, Schinke added, "we do everything in our power to help these animals." A single shot to the head is usually what it takes to kill the animal instantly. Their shelters kill vastly more cats and dogs than do those run by the ASPCA. In 2019, PETA helped more than 26,000 companion animals in more than 250 cities, including by providing more than 12,500 dogs and cats with spay/neuter services. In the following excerpt from his blog, he reveals that Newkirk admits to killing animals that are "adoptable": In a December 2, 2008, interview with George Stroumboulopoulos of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Stroumboulopoulos asks Newkirk: "Do you euthanize those pets, the adoptable ones, if you get them?" According to Daphna Nachminovitch, PETA’s vice president of cruelty investigations, “Our euthanasia program has never been a secret. The majority of adoptable dogs are never brought through our doors—we refer them to local adoption groups and walk-in animal shelters. The harsh reality behind the grim numbers, she noted, should never be forgotten: "Millions of homeless animals are euthanized in animal shelters and veterinary offices across America because of simple math: too many animals and not enough suitable homes.". Nathan Winograd doesn't think so. And that was just one of the dozens of sad cases that we see every week. PETA shelters have been known to euthanize over 90% of the animals that are rendered into their care, adopting out only a small handful. Read the lame defense “Your Mommy Kills Animals” PETA has handed out a graphic comic to children titled, “Your Mommy Kills Animals” while also funding arsonists and terrorist groups. Winograd thus concludes that PETA's claim that it kills so many animals because they are unadoptable is, as he puts it, "a lie." Why PETA Euthanizes is a Mary Tully production.